I picked this up expecting a straightforward historical novel, and instead found myself completely swept up in a story that manages to be both deeply moving and oddly life-affirming. The premise alone is captivatingâa modern-day auctioneer discovers a diary belonging to Johanna Bonger, the woman who essentially saved Vincent van Gogh's artistic legacy from obscurity. But what struck me most was how the book weaves between past and present, letting Johanna's quiet determination mirror Emsley's own struggles in unexpected ways.
What makes this work so well is the emotional texture. The author doesn't shy away from the genuine hardship of Johanna's situationâa young widow in 1800s Paris with a child, speaking barely any French, and inheriting a collection of paintings nobody wanted. Yet there's an undercurrent of humor and resilience that keeps the story from ever feeling heavy-handed or depressing. I found myself laughing out loud one moment and genuinely moved the next, which is harder to pull off than it sounds.
Why you should read
- Discover the remarkable true story of the woman behind van Gogh's enduring fame.
- Experience a beautifully woven dual timeline that feels both intimate and sweeping.
- Encounter unexpected parallels between past and present that illuminate modern challenges.
- Appreciate nuanced character work that avoids sentimentality while remaining deeply moving.
- Explore themes of legacy, recognition, and the quiet power of determination.
What to expect
- Alternating perspectives between Johanna's past and a contemporary auctioneer's present.
- Reflective, character-driven pacing that prioritizes emotional truth over plot mechanics.
- Lyrical yet accessible prose that honors both historical detail and personal introspection.
- A tone that is contemplative and affirming without veering into sentimentality.
- Moments of quiet revelation that resonate long after the final page.
The dual timeline structure could have felt gimmicky, but instead it creates this lovely resonance between two women separated by generations, both trying to figure out who they are beyond circumstance. Emsley's modern-day struggles feel grounded and real, and watching her find inspiration in Johanna's choices feels earned rather than preachy. The pacing keeps you turning pages, and the historical details feel lived-in rather than researched-to-death.
If you're drawn to character-driven stories with heart, or if you've ever wondered about the people behind famous artists, this will absolutely speak to you. It's the kind of book that lingers after you finish, making you think differently about resilience and legacy.