Cover of The Secrets Below by Camilla Sten

Our score:

4.3 / 5

see on amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Secrets Below

Camilla Sten

Our Review

This atmospheric middle-grade thriller set in the Swedish archipelago manages to blend everyday loneliness with genuine unease in a way that feels both grounded and unsettling. Twelve-year-old Tuva is a quiet, isolated kid who loves her island home of Harö, even when school feels like a struggle. When a classmate vanishes and other people begin disappearing from the surrounding islands, Tuva and Rasmus, the new boy at school, find themselves witnesses to something strange and possibly supernatural happening in the woods near the water.

What works really well here is the mood. The cold, rocky islands and the dark forests create a palpable sense of isolation, and Sten captures that specific kind of childhood fear where you're not sure if what you saw was real or if adults will even believe you. The pacing moves quickly without feeling rushed, and there's a nice balance between the mystery elements and Tuva's more personal struggles with fitting in and finding her voice. The friendship that develops between Tuva and Rasmus feels authentic, built on shared fear and curiosity rather than forced camaraderie.

Why you should read

  • Scandinavian setting delivers authentic atmosphere and bone-deep chill
  • Protagonist observes details others miss, rewarding attentive readers
  • Friendship develops believably without feeling manufactured or rushed
  • Fantasy elements emerge gradually, enhancing rather than overwhelming the mystery
  • Perfect balance of creepy tension and age-appropriate storytelling

What to expect

  • Slow-building tension that rewards patient readers
  • Vivid sensory details of cold, isolation, and dark water
  • First-person narration from a perceptive young protagonist
  • Mystery and fantasy woven together seamlessly
  • Emotionally grounded despite eerie subject matter

The fantasy elements lean more toward eerie folklore than high magic, which suits the setting perfectly. Readers looking for a Narnia-style adventure might find this a bit darker and more grounded than expected, but if your young reader enjoys spooky stories with heart, this hits a sweet spot. It's genuinely tense in places without being traumatizing, and it respects its audience's intelligence. The resolution ties things together satisfyingly, though some readers might wish for a bit more explanation about the supernatural forces at play.

This is ideal for kids around ages ten to thirteen who are ready for something with real stakes and a touch of darkness, especially if they've outgrown purely cozy mysteries but aren't quite ready for full-blown horror. It's a quick, absorbing read that lingers in the imagination afterward.

In a nutshell

Camilla Sten crafts an atmospheric tale that settles into your bones like a Scandinavian winter. The story unfolds on a secluded Swedish island where young Tuva finds herself drawn into unsettling events tied to the dark waters surrounding her isolated community. The setting becomes its own character here — windswept, frigid, and hauntingly beautiful in its remoteness. Tuva makes for a compelling protagonist, someone who watches more than she speaks and notices things others might overlook. Her budding connection with fellow outsider Rasmus develops organically, grounding the supernatural undercurrents in genuine emotional stakes. Sten demonstrates real skill in balancing middle-grade accessibility with genuinely eerie moments, never condescending to younger readers while maintaining appropriate boundaries. The mystery builds with patience, layering clues and atmosphere until the pieces click together in satisfying ways.

Best for

Readers aged 10 and up who enjoy atmospheric mysteries with subtle supernatural threads. Ideal for those who loved the mood of Scandinavian folklore or appreciate stories where setting and character matter as much as plot.

Isolation and community in remote placesFriendship forming between outsidersSecrets hidden beneath calm surfacesComing of age through unsettling discoveriesThe power and danger of natural environmentsTrust and who deserves it

Content notes

  • Disappearances create underlying tension throughout
  • Eerie and suspenseful atmosphere
  • Themes of loss and uncertainty

If you liked this, try

  • The House in the Cerulean Sea — TJ Klune
  • Small Spaces — Katherine Arden
  • The Wild Robot — Peter Brown
  • Winterhouse — Ben Guterson

Reviewed by Book of the Day Editorial Team • Updated 1/29/2026

4.3 - Excellent