Our Score4.5/ 5
Buy on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
EDITION PUBLISHEDFebruary 2011
Themes
Forbidden love across kindsClaiming a power long deniedKnowledge, history, and originsBelonging and prejudice
A Discovery of Witches
A reluctant witch and a centuries-old vampire collide over a bewitched manuscript in the Bodleian Library, igniting a forbidden romance and a supernatural power struggle. Brainy, atmospheric urban fantasy with a slow-burning love story at its core.
The Review
Our take
Deborah Harkness, a historian of science by training, brings a scholar's relish to A Discovery of Witches, and it shows on every page. Her heroine, Diana Bishop, is a Yale historian descended from a famous line of witches who has spent her adult life refusing her own magic, determined to make her way by intellect alone. Then, deep in Oxford's Bodleian Library, she calls up a long-lost alchemical manuscript that has been hidden by an enchantment for centuries — and in doing so announces herself to every witch, vampire, and daemon who has been hunting that book for generations.
Chief among them is Matthew Clairmont, a formidable geneticist who is also a fifteen-hundred-year-old vampire, and the slow-kindling attraction between him and Diana is the engine of the novel. Harkness takes her time with it, and readers who like a true slow burn will be rewarded: the romance unfolds across long walks, shared research, candlelit dinners and quiet confidences, charged with the danger of a forbidden alliance between two kinds the supernatural world forbids to mix. It is a courtship as much intellectual as physical, two brilliant people circling each other, and the patience pays off in real heat.
What sets the book apart from the crowded paranormal-romance shelf is the texture of erudition Harkness layers in. Alchemy, the history of science, wine, yoga, the architecture of Oxford and a French château — she is a generous, immersive guide, and the world feels lived-in and adult rather than merely fanciful. The central mystery of the manuscript, and what it reveals about the origins and decline of the supernatural species, gives the romance a genuine plot to ride on, building toward a conflict with the Congregation, the secretive council that polices relations between the magical races.
The book is not lean. It is long and unhurried, and its pleasures are atmospheric rather than propulsive; a reader craving fast action may grow impatient with the digressions into wine lists and library lore. Matthew, in the protective-alpha mold of the genre, occasionally tips toward the overbearing, and the plot is clearly the opening movement of a trilogy, ending on a deliberate threshold rather than a full resolution. But for readers who want immersion — a romance to sink into and a world to live in for hundreds of pages — those very qualities are the appeal.
Harkness is also unusually good on the texture of being an outsider inside a hidden order. Diana's lifelong attempt to live as a human, to suppress an inheritance she finds frightening, gives the magic real psychological weight; her power, when it finally begins to surface, reads less like wish fulfillment than like the return of something she has spent decades fearing. That emotional undercurrent keeps the fantasy grounded even at its most extravagant.
Why you should read
- You love a slow-burn romance between a witch and a vampire
- You want urban fantasy with real erudition and atmosphere
- You enjoy immersive, long, world-rich novels
- You like a brainy heroine and an intellectual courtship
What to expect
- A patient, slow-burning forbidden romance
- Witches, vampires, and daemons in a modern hidden world
- Rich historical and scientific texture
- The opening volume of a trilogy
It is smart, sensuous, and absorbing, the rare paranormal romance that respects its reader's intelligence as much as their pulse. Settle in with a glass of something good; this one means to keep you up late.
Reviewed by Rowan
4.5 - Outstanding
Buy on Amazon →
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.