A daily review of books worth your time
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Neil Gaiman drops an ordinary London businessman through the cracks of his own city into London Below — a shadow-world of monsters, angels, and forgotten people beneath the streets. A witty, dark, foundational work of modern urban fantasy.
The Review
Richard Mayhew has a tidy life, a demanding fiancée, and no reason to expect adventure, until the evening he stops to help a bleeding girl named Door slumped on a London sidewalk. That single act of decency erases him from the world he knew: his apartment is let to strangers, his colleagues no longer recognize him, and he tumbles out of ordinary London and into London Below, the secret city that exists in the sewers, the abandoned Tube stations, and the forgotten spaces beneath the one above. Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere takes that premise and runs with a dark, gleeful invention that helped define what urban fantasy could be.
The great pleasure of the book is its world-building by pun and rumor. London Below is populated by the literalized ghosts of the city's own map — there is an actual Earl holding court in a train at Earl's Court, an Angel called Islington, a treacherous bridge of Night, a market that floats from impossible location to impossible location. Gaiman mines the names of the real city for a whole mythology, and the effect is delightful: a reader who knows London will keep grinning, and one who doesn't will simply enjoy the strangeness. Richard's journey across this underworld, in the company of Door, the wary bodyguard Hunter, and the magnificently unreliable Marquis de Carabas, gives the novel the shape of a classic quest.
Gaiman also supplies a pair of genuinely frightening villains in Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar, an assassin double-act whose courtly menace and casual cruelty give the book real stakes. The tone throughout is the Gaiman signature — fairy-tale logic delivered with a dry, modern wit, whimsy shadowed by genuine darkness — and it moves at a brisk, propulsive clip that the longer-winded epics of the genre rarely match.
Beneath the adventure runs a quieter, sadder idea. The people of London Below are, many of them, the city's discarded — the homeless, the overlooked, those who slipped out of the world above and were forgotten by everyone who once knew them. Gaiman never belabors the parallel, but it gives the fantasy a sting of real-world feeling: the book asks, gently, who we stop seeing, and what becomes of them. Richard's growing refusal to look away is the truest arc in the novel.
This is, it should be said, an early work, and it shows in places. Richard is a somewhat passive hero, swept along by events more than driving them, and a few of the underworld's wonders are sketched rather than developed. The plot follows the well-worn beats of the portal quest. But these are minor complaints against a book bursting with imagination, and the central conceit — that there is a whole forgotten city living in the gaps of our own, peopled by those who have fallen through the cracks — has a melancholy resonance that lingers well past the last page.
For anyone wanting to understand where so much contemporary urban fantasy comes from, this is a foundational text, and a thoroughly entertaining one. It makes the familiar city strange and the strange city home.
Reviewed by Rowan
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.