A daily review of books worth your time
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
A spectral hound stalks a cursed family across the fog-bound moor, and Sherlock Holmes must decide whether the killer is a legend or a man. Doyle's most atmospheric case, and arguably his best.
The Review
The Hound of the Baskervilles is the novel where Arthur Conan Doyle's cold-blooded logician collides with full-blooded Gothic dread, and the friction makes it the finest of the Holmes stories. A country squire dies on the moor near Baskerville Hall, his face frozen in terror, near the prints of a gigantic hound. An ancient family curse promises exactly such a death. When the last of the Baskervilles arrives from abroad to take up his inheritance, Holmes is engaged to keep him alive, and the novel becomes a contest between two ways of seeing the world: the supernatural explanation everyone on the moor believes, and the rational one Holmes refuses to abandon.
What makes the book sing is its atmosphere. Dartmoor is rendered as a character in its own right, all mist and bog and the boom of the great Grimpen Mire waiting to swallow the careless. Doyle keeps Holmes offstage for a long central stretch, leaving Dr. Watson alone to send back nervous dispatches from the Hall, and that absence is a brilliant stroke. Without the great detective's reassuring certainty, the reader feels the full weight of the legend, the howls in the dark, the figure on the tor, the sense that reason may not be enough out here. It is genuinely frightening in a way few classic mysteries attempt, and the Gothic machinery is deployed with real craft rather than cheap effect.
As detection it is satisfyingly fair. The clues are present, the misdirection is honest, and Holmes's eventual explanation accounts for the terror without dissolving it entirely; even solved, the moor keeps some of its menace. The pleasure is in watching a relentlessly material mind refuse to flinch before a story designed to make it flinch. Doyle understood that the scariest monster is one that might, on inspection, turn out to be a man with a motive, and the resolution honors both the fear and the logic. Modern readers will spot the period's class assumptions and the occasionally creaky Victorian melodrama, but these are minor against the book's command of mood.
It works beautifully as a standalone, requiring no prior acquaintance with the canon, which is part of why it has been adapted more often than any other Holmes tale. Read it on a dark evening and the moor will get into you. Doyle blends the comfort of the puzzle with the chill of the ghost story so seamlessly that you never have to choose between them, and the result is a short, propulsive, deeply atmospheric novel that has lost none of its power to make a reader glance at the window. It is the rare classic that delivers exactly what its reputation promises, a perfect gateway for anyone who has somehow never read a Holmes story and a reliable comfort for those who have read them all. The hound has outlived a century of imitators because Doyle never let the chill and the logic cancel each other out; he made them partners.
Reviewed by Quinn
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.