Everyone who has read the original trilogy already knows how Haymitch ends up. That is the problem Suzanne Collins sets herself in Sunrise on the Reaping, and the surprise is how little it matters that you know. The book takes a character we met as a drunk and a cynic and makes the reader sit through every step that got him there, with no hope of rescuing him.
The setup is a cruel bit of worldbuilding arithmetic. It's the fiftieth Hunger Games, a Quarter Quell, and the Capitol celebrates by doubling the haul: four tributes from each district, two boys and two girls, forty-eight in all. In District 12, Haymitch is trying not to think about his odds and mostly thinking about the girl he loves. Then his name is called. Collins opens on reaping day, just as she did in the first Hunger Games book, and the echo is deliberate and a little chilling. You recognize the ritual, and you dread it anyway.
What I love about the doubled Games, as a rule of this world, is what it costs. More tributes means more people the reader has to care about, and more people the book is going to take away. Haymitch is shipped to the Capitol with three other District 12 tributes, a mismatched group drawn from his own corner of the world. It's a small, odd, believable crew, and the growth between them is one of the things readers single out most warmly. It also means the arena has a body count you feel. Collins keeps pushing on one question, which is how many people a single system can chew up before it needs to be called what it is.
The Games themselves are brutal, and Collins doesn't look away, but the book's real argument lives outside the arena. The tension isn't only whether Haymitch survives; it's what survival will be made to cost him afterward, and the dread of that sits under every scene in the arena. Haymitch figures out early that he has been set up to fail, and the Capitol's reach turns out to run straight into the districts and into the lives of everyone near him. President Snow is firmly in power here, and the cruelty Katniss later suffers is aimed at Haymitch first. Readers keep returning to the same point: he wins, and winning is treated as the offense. It's a bleak idea, and the book says it out loud.
Collins also spends the book threading the larger world together. Effie turns up. So does an early glimpse of Plutarch plotting against the status quo, and Beetee, Wiress and Mags all have a part. Fans of the first three books and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes will keep catching small echoes, the kind that make you want to reread the trilogy the minute you finish. It makes the whole run of five books feel like one long, planned argument about war and power. This is the more political of the Panem stories too, and it handles that without slowing down.
The prose stays plain and fast, which suits a story this grim, and the emotional load is heavy. Longtime fans describe going back into Panem and falling for it all over again, even while it breaks their hearts. Some finish it in a couple of sittings, then need a minute. It's relentlessly dark, even by this series' standards, and the final stretch piles loss on loss. A few readers felt the middle sagged a little and that some of the tributes deserved more room before the Games begin; Lou Lou comes up by name. That complaint has weight. The trilogy let you love its tributes before it broke them, and here a couple of lives are sketched lighter than the grief they trigger. It's a fair mark against a book that otherwise works hard on character.
Why you should read
- Hunger Games fans who want Haymitch's backstory
- Readers of dark, political dystopian fiction
- Anyone who wants the full Panem timeline in order
- Young adult readers ready for a heavy, grief-soaked story
What to expect
- Fast, plain prose with a heavy emotional load
- A Quarter Quell with double the tributes
- Familiar Panem names turning up in earlier days
- A bleak run of losses before an epilogue with some light
The epilogue gets special attention from readers, and I'll leave it alone beyond saying that it adds a note of light to a story that has given out very little of it. Sunrise on the Reaping doesn't rewrite Haymitch. It just gives his bitterness a history, and once you have it you can't un-know it. The next time you meet the bitter mentor in the trilogy, you'll see everyone he's still carrying.