A daily review of books worth your time
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Jesse Q. Sutanto finds a dead man in a lonely widow's failing San Francisco tea shop and lets the widow decide she'll solve it better than the police. The result is a cozy mystery powered almost entirely by its narrator — a meddling, big-hearted force of nature whose detective work is really a campaign to collect the lost people around her.
The Review
Vera Wong is the engine, the charm, and the whole reason this works. She is a sixtysomething widow rattling around above a tea shop nobody visits, texting her grown son daily reminders he ignores, keeping a routine so empty it aches. Then she comes downstairs to a corpse on her floor and a flash drive in its hand — and instead of leaving it to the authorities, she pockets the evidence and appoints herself lead investigator, certain that no detective alive can match a suspicious mother with time on her hands. Sutanto knows the joke and never overplays it: Vera's confidence is funny because it is also, frequently, correct.
As a mystery the book is gentle by design. A handful of suspects drift into Vera's orbit — people connected to the dead man, each lonely or adrift in their own way — and Vera, naturally, decides to feed them, mother them, and interrogate them more or less simultaneously. The clues are fairly laid and the culprit is reachable by an attentive reader, but anyone hunting for a tightly wound puzzle should adjust expectations. The pleasure here is not the deduction; it is watching a found family assemble around a woman who insists on caring for everyone within reach whether they like it or not. The dumplings get as much page time as the deductions, and that is the point.
What lifts it above the cozy average is how much genuine feeling Sutanto pours into the loneliness underneath the comedy. Vera's grief, her estrangement from a son who finds her exhausting, her terror of having become invisible — these give the warmth real stakes, so that the gathering of misfits at her table reads as something earned rather than cute. Sutanto writes the food, the city, and Vera's relentless interior monologue with obvious affection, and the voice is strong enough to carry stretches where the plot is just marking time between meals.
Readers should calibrate. The mystery is light and the eventual solution leans more on emotional logic than airtight detection; a couple of the suspects soften from persons of interest into surrogate children a little too neatly, and the tone stays cozy even when the material flirts with something darker. Anyone wanting menace or a fair-play stumper will find this too gentle, and the sentimentality, while well earned, is laid on thick by the close. This is comfort reading that knows exactly what it is.
Taken on its own terms, it is a delight — a murder mystery that uses its corpse mostly as an excuse to throw a dinner party, anchored by a narrator who deserves to headline a long series. If you come for the crime you may leave a touch unsatisfied; if you come for Vera, you will want to move into the apartment above the tea shop and let her order you around. It is the rare cozy where the heart is the whole case.
Reviewed by Quinn
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.