Spring Reads 2025: Discover your next favorite book for the season of renewal
Book cover of The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny and Murder by David Grann

Our score:

4.5 / 5

see on amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny and Murder

David Grann

Our Review:

An outstanding narrative nonfiction work, "The Wager" by David Grann vividly depicts a remarkable story of mutiny, survival, and the intricacies of human nature under the most trying of circumstances. Readers are whisked away to the 18th century, on board the tragic HMS Wager, as Grann's research and captivating storytelling immerse them in Britain's imperial battle with Spain.

It is remarkable how the author skillfully incorporates many viewpoints from court martial records, historical narratives, and logbooks. Using vivid detail, Grann recreates the terrifying voyage of the Wager's crew, from the perilous trip around Cape Horn to their fight for survival on a lonely island off the coast of Patagonia. The resultant story is historically grounded and as riveting as any fiction thriller.

Captain David Cheap, Gunner's Mate John Bulkeley, and the other characters in this sea drama are vividly brought to life by Grann's exceptional character development. Insight into the mental toll of their situation is provided by the nuanced and detailed portrayal of the crew's internal tensions and power struggles.

Examining larger ideas like empire, power, and justice is a strong suit of the work. Grann expertly adds depth to an otherwise simple adventure story by using the Wager incident to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of British imperialism.

Although the pace is superb throughout, the first few chapters may be tedious for certain readers as Grann sets the historical background. Nonetheless, as the plot advances, this small detail is soon disregarded.

In addition to retelling historical events, "The Wager" offers a perceptive analysis of the factors that influence narrative construction and the exclusion of some groups from historical accounts. The strength of meticulous research supported by expert storytelling is on full display in Grann's writing.

An engaging read that will stay with readers long after they have finished "The Wager"—whether they are interested in history, adventure, or just love a good real story. This book is both intellectually stimulating and utterly engrossing; Grann has once again demonstrated why he is one of the greatest living nonfiction authors.

4.5 - Outstanding