A daily review of books worth your time
More like this
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Jason Rekulak hands his recovering-addict nanny a five-year-old whose crayon drawings start depicting a murder she could not have witnessed, and builds a supernatural thriller that uses the pictures themselves — printed right on the page — as its scariest device. It is a clever, propulsive horror-mystery that knows exactly when to let an image do the work.
The Review
The premise is the kind that could curdle in lesser hands, and Rekulak keeps it sharp. Mallory Quinn, fresh out of rehab and rebuilding a life one routine at a time, takes a live-in job minding Teddy, the quiet son of an affluent suburban couple. Teddy draws constantly, the usual small-child fare, until the day his pictures turn: a figure in the woods, a body, scenes rendered with a skill and a darkness no kindergartner should possess. The book reproduces these drawings on the page as it goes, and the device is genuinely unnerving — watching the art mature from stick figures into something accomplished and wrong is more effective than any amount of described dread.
Rekulak structures the thing as a dual mystery. On one track is the supernatural question: who is drawing through Teddy, and what does she want told. On the other is the human one: Mallory's fragile sobriety, the gaps in the family's too-perfect story, and the steady erosion of whether her own perceptions can be trusted given where she's been. The book moves fast and chapters end where they should. Rekulak is good at the mechanics of escalation, raising the stakes on a tight clock while seeding the clues a careful reader can try to assemble before the reveal. For a long stretch it functions beautifully as both a ghost story and a paranoid character study about a woman fighting to be believed.
The pleasures here are real and worth naming. The voice is warm and grounded, which makes the eerie material land harder; Mallory is easy to root for, and her relationship with Teddy gives the horror an emotional anchor. The middle stretch, where the drawings grow more explicit and Mallory's amateur investigation collides with the family's evasions, is tense and confidently paced. This is a writer who understands that a thriller is a promise to keep the reader leaning forward, and he keeps it.
Where opinions will split is the resolution. Without spoiling it, Rekulak makes a structural choice in the final act that swaps one kind of story for another, and the swap is divisive by design — bold and satisfying to some, an overreach to others who preferred the quieter dread of the setup. A couple of supporting characters are drawn thin enough to serve the plot's needs, and the wealthy-suburb trappings can feel like familiar furniture. Readers who want their horror to stay in one lane may feel the late turn yanks the wheel.
Still, this is an assured, hard-to-put-down entertainment that delivers on its hook. The drawings alone justify the experience, and the combination of supernatural mystery, addiction-shadowed unreliability, and brisk plotting makes for a book that respects your time and your appetite for a scare. Go in for the premise, stay for how cleanly Rekulak springs his traps, and decide for yourself whether the ending sticks the landing.
Reviewed by Quinn
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.