
Our score:
4.4 / 5
What Might Have Been
Marianne PlunkertOur Review:
Plunkert's "What Might Have Been" delivers a captivating historical romance set against the rugged backdrop of the Colorado territory. The narrative follows Melissa Sullivan's journey from desperate stowaway to a woman determined to forge her own path in a world dominated by men. Plunkert skillfully balances period authenticity with contemporary sensibilities, crafting characters whose struggles for autonomy and respect resonate across time.
The prose flows with measured elegance, neither rushing the romantic tension nor dwelling too long on historical minutiae. Particularly noteworthy is Plunkert's deft handling of the power dynamics between Melissa and Lieutenant Bellamy, whose initial antagonism evolves organically through meaningful character development. The themes of female independence and the reconciliation of pride with vulnerability are woven throughout without overwhelming the central romance.
Readers of historical fiction who appreciate strong-willed heroines will find much to admire in Melissa's determination to escape predetermined roles. The novel should especially appeal to fans of western-set romances who prefer their love stories with substantial character growth and genuine obstacles rather than contrived misunderstandings. The Colorado territory setting provides a vivid canvas for both adventure and quieter moments of connection.
"What Might Have Been" stands out in the historical romance genre for its commitment to character integrity. Neither Melissa nor Nathaniel sacrifice their essential natures for an easy resolution, making their eventual connection all the more satisfying. Plunkert has crafted a romance that honors both the constraints of its historical setting and the timeless desire for partnership based on mutual respect rather than dominance.